Implants, orthodontic aligners, veneers and whitening are now some of the most commonly marketed treatments in UK dentistry, and they share features that make consent harder than it looks. They are often elective, they are usually paid for privately, they run over several appointments, and the patient's expectations are shaped as much by advertising as by the clinical assessment. The Supreme Court's decision in Montgomery changed the legal test for what a patient must be told, and the General Dental Council sets its own detailed standard for how consent is obtained and recorded. Together they mean that a signed form, on its own, proves very little.
This article explains what Montgomery and McCulloch mean for consent in dental practice, what the GDC Standards for the Dental Team require, and how those rules apply to implants, orthodontics and cosmetic dentistry. It is written for dentists, orthodontists, dental therapists and hygienists, clinical dental technicians and practice owners. It is also relevant to doctors, nurses and pharmacist prescribers who work alongside dentists in mixed clinics offering facial treatments, because the legal test for consent is the same whoever holds the conversation.
What does Montgomery mean for dental consent?
In Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board [2015] UKSC 11, the Supreme Court held at paragraph 87 that an adult of sound mind is entitled to decide which, if any, of the available forms of treatment to undergo. The clinician is therefore under a duty to take reasonable care to ensure that the patient is aware of any material risks involved in any recommended treatment, and of any reasonable alternative or variant treatments. The court defined materiality in two parts: whether "a reasonable person in the patient's position would be likely to attach significance to the risk, or the doctor is or should reasonably be aware that the particular patient would be likely to attach significance to it."
Montgomery was a medical case and the judgment speaks of doctors. The GDC's standards, however, express the same patient-centred approach for the whole dental team. Standard 3.1.3 tells dental professionals to find out what patients want to know as well as what the clinician thinks they need to know. Our explainer on Montgomery and material risk covers the case in more depth, and the Bolam test page explains the standard of care that still governs diagnosis and treatment itself.
Paragraph 89 adds that "the assessment of whether a risk is material cannot be reduced to percentages." The court listed the factors that shape significance: the nature of the risk, the effect its occurrence would have on the patient's life, the importance to the patient of the benefits sought, the alternatives available, and the risks of those alternatives. In elective dentistry the benefits sought are often aesthetic, so a risk that would be acceptable in treating disease may weigh differently for a patient who is choosing treatment to change the appearance of their smile.
Paragraph 90 makes the point every practice should take from the case. The duty involves dialogue, and the information must be comprehensible. The court said the duty is not fulfilled by "bombarding the patient with technical information which she cannot reasonably be expected to grasp, let alone by routinely demanding her signature on a consent form."
Which alternatives must a dentist discuss?
Montgomery left open how a clinician decides which alternatives are reasonable. The Supreme Court answered that in McCulloch v Forth Valley Health Board [2023] UKSC 26. It held that the professional practice test applies: narrowing the possible options down to the reasonable ones is an exercise of clinical judgement, assessed against what a responsible body of opinion would accept. Once that judgement is made, paragraph 57 says the clinician must explain the recommended option and each of the other reasonable options, "plus no treatment if that is a reasonable alternative option", with their respective advantages, disadvantages and material risks. Paragraph 58 stresses that the clinician cannot simply inform the patient about the option the clinician prefers. Our page on McCulloch and reasonable alternatives sets out the reasoning.
Check your understanding
Illustrative scenario: a patient asks to replace a missing lower molar with an implant. The dentist considers an implant, a bridge, a partial denture and leaving the space all to be reasonable options in this patient's case, and recommends the implant. What does McCulloch require?
McCulloch, paragraph 57: once the clinician has decided, with the support of a responsible body of opinion, which options are reasonable, the duty is to explain each of them, plus no treatment where that is reasonable, with their advantages, disadvantages and material risks. Options the clinician reasonably judges not to be reasonable need not be listed. The scenario is illustrative and is not a real case; which options are reasonable is a clinical judgement on the facts.
What the GDC Standards for the Dental Team require on consent
Principle 3 of the GDC Standards for the Dental Team is "Obtain valid consent". Standard 3.1 requires dental professionals to obtain valid consent before starting treatment, "explaining all the relevant options and the possible costs". Guidance 3.1.1 adds that this applies whether you are the first member of the team to see the patient or are involved later, and that you should not assume that someone else has obtained consent. That point matters in practices where a treatment coordinator, a hygienist or a referring colleague has had the earlier conversations.
8
items are listed in GDC guidance 3.1.3 as things patients might want to know, including the options and their risks and benefits, your recommended option, the cost, what might happen without treatment, and whether the treatment is guaranteed, for how long and with what exclusions.
The record matters as much as the conversation. Guidance 3.1.2 says that although a signature on a form is important in verifying that a patient has given consent, "it is the discussions that take place with the patient that determine whether the consent is valid." Guidance 3.1.4 requires you to check and document that patients have understood the information. Guidance 3.1.6 requires written consent where treatment involves conscious sedation or general anaesthetic. Standard 3.2 requires that patients are given sufficient information and a reasonable amount of time to consider it, in a format they can easily understand. For a line-by-line approach to the note itself, see our article on what consultation notes should record, which applies equally to dental records.
Consent over a course of treatment: implants and orthodontics
Implant and orthodontic treatment rarely happens in a single visit, and the GDC treats consent as something that runs for the whole course. Standard 3.3 requires that consent remains valid at each stage of investigation or treatment. Guidance 3.3.1 describes consent as "a process, not a one-off event". Guidance 3.3.2 requires specific consent for what you are going to do at each appointment, and 3.3.5 requires fresh consent, documented, if you need to change the agreed treatment or the estimated cost. Guidance 3.1.5 confirms that a patient may withdraw consent or ask for treatment to stop after it has started, and that you must explain the consequences and record the discussion.
By treatment
Choose a treatment to see the consent points that apply to it.
Explain each reasonable option, including leaving the space where that is reasonable, with its advantages, disadvantages and material risks (McCulloch, paragraph 57). Give the costs and any guarantee and its exclusions (GDC 3.1, 3.1.3). Obtain written consent if sedation is used (GDC 3.1.6), confirm consent at each surgical and restorative stage, and consent again if the plan or estimate changes (GDC 3.3.2, 3.3.5).
The GDC says there is at present no effective substitute for a physical clinical examination as the foundation for assessing suitability for orthodontic treatment. The treating dentist must explain the options and obtain valid consent at the outset and throughout, and the patient must know the full name of the dental professional responsible and be able to contact them directly.
Products releasing between 0.1% and 6% hydrogen peroxide may only be supplied through a dentist, dental hygienist, dental therapist or clinical dental technician, after an appropriate clinical examination, and may not be used on anyone under 18 except wholly to treat or prevent disease. Higher concentrations are prohibited for cosmetic use. The first use in each cycle must be carried out by, or under the direct supervision of, a dental practitioner.
Remote and direct-to-consumer aligners
Clear aligners are increasingly offered through remote models, and the GDC addressed this in its statement on direct-to-consumer orthodontic treatment. The statement accepts that some interactions can be provided safely on a remote platform. It also says that clinical judgements about suitability must be based on a full assessment of the patient's oral health and that "there is no effective substitute for a physical, clinical examination as the foundation for that assessment." Where a dentist relies on another professional's examination, the responsibility for the judgement "rests wholly with the prescribing dentist".
On consent, the statement says the treating dentist must explain the treatment options available and obtain valid consent "both at the outset and throughout any course of treatment", and describes direct interaction between patient and practitioner as essential. The same tension between convenience and in-person assessment arises in medicine, as our article on remote prescribing of botulinum toxin explains.
Tooth whitening: the law behind the consent conversation
Whitening is the area of cosmetic dentistry where consent sits on top of criminal law. The GDC's position statement on tooth whitening, dated 11 July 2016, says it is illegal to supply or administer products containing or releasing more than 6% hydrogen peroxide for cosmetic purposes. Products releasing between 0.1% and 6% may only be made available through treatment by a dentist, dental hygienist, dental therapist or clinical dental technician, after an appropriate clinical examination, and cannot be used on anyone under 18 except where the use is intended wholly for treating or preventing disease. The statement notes that breach is a criminal offence and that whitening falls within the practice of dentistry under the Dentists Act 1984, so it may only be provided by GDC registrants.
Children and young people
Orthodontic treatment is often started in adolescence, so the question of who can consent arises frequently. In England and Wales, section 8 of the Family Law Reform Act 1969 provides that the consent of a minor aged 16 or over "to any surgical, medical or dental treatment" is as effective as if they were of full age. The NHS explains that a child under 16 may consent if they have enough intelligence, competence and understanding to fully appreciate what is involved, which is known as being Gillick competent, and that otherwise a person with parental responsibility can consent. For patients aged 16 and over, capacity is assessed under the Mental Capacity Act 2005. The law differs in Scotland and Northern Ireland, and practices there should check the position that applies to them.
Common assumptions
Tap each card to compare the assumption with the position.
What CQC expects of dental practices on consent
Dental practices registered with the Care Quality Commission in England must also meet regulation 11 of the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014, which says care and treatment must only be provided with the consent of the relevant person. CQC's guidance on regulation 11 says the information given should include the risks, complications and any alternatives, and should come from a person with the necessary knowledge and understanding of the treatment. It says consent procedures must make sure people are not pressured into giving consent, and that consent policies must reflect current legislation and guidance. CQC states that it can prosecute for a breach of regulation 11 and can move directly to prosecution without first serving a warning notice. Our guide to the consent process and our governance page cover how policies, training and audit fit together.
Are the GDC standards about to change?
On 2 June 2026 the GDC launched a consultation on proposals to replace the Standards for the Dental Team with a new Framework for Professionalism, made up of four Principles of Professionalism supported by expectations, statutory professional guidance and practical resources. The consultation ran until 31 August 2026. The GDC said the proposals "are not about changing the expectations on dental professionals" but about making it easier to apply professional judgement. These remain proposals. At the time of writing the Standards for the Dental Team are the GDC's published standards, and the legal test in Montgomery and McCulloch does not depend on which document the GDC uses.
What to do in practice
- Map each elective treatment you offer, such as implants, aligners, veneers and whitening, to the options you would consider reasonable for a typical patient, so that the alternatives conversation is planned rather than improvised.
- Give a written treatment plan that sets out the options discussed, the recommended option, the costs and any guarantee with its exclusions, and allow the patient time to consider it before treatment starts.
- Record the discussion, not just the signature: the risks and alternatives covered, the patient's questions and priorities, and how you checked their understanding.
- Confirm and record consent at each appointment of an ongoing course, and obtain fresh documented consent if the plan or the estimate changes.
- Make sure the clinician who will provide the treatment holds or confirms the consent discussion, even where a coordinator or colleague has had earlier conversations.
- For younger patients, record who gave consent and on what basis, whether the young person themselves, a person with parental responsibility, or both.
Interactive
Would your consent records for elective dental treatment stand up?
Tick each item your practice does routinely. Nothing you select is sent anywhere.
Consent disputes in dentistry are usually decided on the record of what was discussed. An independent consent audit can review your plans, forms and notes against Montgomery, McCulloch and the GDC standards, and the free Medicolegal Readiness Score gives a quick view of where your systems stand. For the wider picture across facial and cosmetic treatments, our complete guide to consent in aesthetic practice and our medical aesthetics page cover the treatments many dental practices now also offer. If a patient has already raised a concern, our guide on responding to a patient complaint explains the first steps, and a live complaint or claim should be discussed with your indemnity provider.
Frequently asked questions
Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board [2015] UKSC 11 was a medical case, but it sets the legal duty to take reasonable care to ensure a patient is aware of material risks and reasonable alternatives before treatment. The GDC Standards for the Dental Team build the same patient-centred approach into dental consent, including finding out what the patient wants to know.
No. GDC guidance 3.1.2 says a signature is important in verifying consent, but it is the discussions with the patient that determine whether consent is valid. The Supreme Court in Montgomery also said the duty is not fulfilled by routinely demanding a signature on a consent form.
Under McCulloch v Forth Valley Health Board [2023] UKSC 26, you must explain every option you reasonably consider to be a reasonable alternative, plus no treatment where that is reasonable, with their advantages, disadvantages and material risks. Which options are reasonable is a matter of clinical judgement supported by a responsible body of opinion.
GDC guidance 3.1.6 requires written consent where treatment involves conscious sedation or general anaesthetic. For all treatment, the GDC expects the consent discussion to be documented and the patient's understanding to be checked and recorded.
In England and Wales, section 8 of the Family Law Reform Act 1969 makes the consent of a person aged 16 or over to dental treatment as effective as an adult's. Under 16, a young person may consent if they are Gillick competent; otherwise a person with parental responsibility can consent.
Sources
- Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board [2015] UKSC 11, judgment, paragraphs 87 to 90, The National Archives, Find Case Law.
- McCulloch and others v Forth Valley Health Board [2023] UKSC 26, judgment, paragraphs 57 and 58, The National Archives, Find Case Law.
- General Dental Council. Standards for the Dental Team, Principle 3: Obtain valid consent, standards 3.1 to 3.3 and guidance.
- General Dental Council. Principle 3: frequently asked questions.
- General Dental Council. Statement on direct-to-consumer orthodontic treatment.
- General Dental Council. Tooth whitening position statement, 11 July 2016.
- General Dental Council. GDC consults on replacing the 'silver book' with new professionalism framework, 2 June 2026.
- The Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014, regulation 11, Need for consent, legislation.gov.uk.
- Care Quality Commission. Regulation 11: Need for consent, guidance for providers.
- Family Law Reform Act 1969, section 8, legislation.gov.uk.
- Mental Capacity Act 2005, section 3, legislation.gov.uk.
- NHS. Consent to treatment: children and young people.
Filed under: Consent · Dentistry · Governance



