Consent is the single issue that decides most complaints in aesthetic practice, and it is the one most often misunderstood. Many clinics still treat consent as a form to be signed on the day, when the law treats it as a conversation that has to happen properly and be recorded. This guide brings the whole subject together in one place: what the courts require, who must take consent and when, how much time a patient needs, how capacity is judged, what the record must contain, and how the same duties reach photographs, data and every profession that offers these treatments.
It is written for everyone who carries the clinical risk of a cosmetic procedure, whether surgical or non-surgical: aesthetic doctors, nurses and dentists, plastic and oculoplastic surgeons, GPs and pharmacist prescribers offering injectables or wellbeing treatments, and the clinic owners and managers who set the consent process. It is general information for clinicians and not legal advice, and any live complaint or claim should go to your indemnity provider or a solicitor. Each section links to a fuller article on that topic.
What the law actually requires: Montgomery and material risk
The modern law of consent in the UK comes from the Supreme Court. In Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board [2015] UKSC 11, the court held that a clinician must take reasonable care to ensure that the patient is aware of any material risks involved in the proposed treatment, and of any reasonable alternatives. A risk is material if a reasonable person in the patient's position would be likely to attach significance to it, or if the clinician is or should reasonably be aware that this particular patient would attach significance to it. The test is tailored to the individual, which is why a standard risk sheet handed over without discussion does not discharge it.
In McCulloch and others v Forth Valley Health Board [2023] UKSC 26, the court clarified how reasonable alternatives are identified, confirming that the range of reasonable alternative treatments is a matter of professional judgement, but that once an alternative is reasonable the duty to discuss it with the patient follows from Montgomery. For cosmetic work the most important reasonable alternative is almost always the option of no treatment at all, and a record that does not show that this was discussed is exposed.
Who must take consent, and when
The GMC guidance for doctors who offer cosmetic interventions, in effect since 1 June 2016, is explicit that consent is personal to the treating clinician. It summarises its themes as including "making sure that you get consent from your patient yourself", and it applies to surgical and non-surgical interventions alike. For surgery, the Royal College of Surgeons of England's Professional Standards for Cosmetic Surgery ask that consent be "obtained in writing by the operating surgeon". The common thread is that the person who will carry out the procedure is the person who should hold the consent discussion, not a receptionist, a therapist or a salesperson.
This matters most where treatment is delegated. A prescriber who authorises a toxin but never meets the patient, or a doctor who signs off a plan that someone else will inject, still carries responsibility for the adequacy of the consent. Our article on remote prescribing of botulinum toxin sets out what each regulator expects of the prescriber's own assessment, which is part of the same question of who is genuinely responsible for the decision.
Time for reflection and the two-stage model
Consent taken under time pressure is hard to defend. The GMC guidance requires doctors to "give the patient the time and information they need to reach a voluntary and informed decision", and says the amount of time depends on the invasiveness, complexity, permanence and risks of the intervention. For cosmetic surgery the Royal College of Surgeons goes further and recommends a two-stage consent process with a cooling-off period of at least two weeks between the stages, taken by the operating surgeon. There is no single fixed period for non-surgical treatment, but the principle of proportionate time for reflection runs through every regulator. Our guide to cooling-off periods for cosmetic procedures sets out exactly what each source says and how to record it.
2 weeks
is the minimum cooling-off period between the two stages of consent recommended for cosmetic surgery by the Royal College of Surgeons of England. For non-surgical treatment the time must still be proportionate to the intervention.
Capacity: the Mental Capacity Act test
Valid consent requires capacity, and capacity in England and Wales is governed by the Mental Capacity Act 2005. The Act sets out five principles. The first is a presumption: "A person must be assumed to have capacity unless it is established that he lacks capacity." The Act also protects autonomy, stating that "A person is not to be treated as unable to make a decision merely because he makes an unwise decision." A patient's choice to proceed with a procedure you would not recommend is not, by itself, evidence that they lack capacity.
Where capacity is in genuine doubt, section 3 sets a four-part test. A person is unable to make a decision if they are unable "to understand the information relevant to the decision", "to retain that information", "to use or weigh that information as part of the process of making the decision", or "to communicate his decision". The inability must arise, under section 2, "because of an impairment of, or a disturbance in the functioning of, the mind or brain". Capacity is decision-specific and time-specific, so the question is always whether this patient can make this decision now, and the assessment belongs in the record.
Vulnerability, expectations and psychological screening
The GMC guidance requires doctors to "consider their vulnerabilities and psychological needs" when discussing cosmetic interventions, and to satisfy themselves that the request is voluntary. In practice this means being alert to mismatched or unrealistic expectations, to pressure from a partner or from social media, and to features that may suggest body dysmorphic disorder, where treatment is unlikely to help and may cause harm. NICE has since proposed a structured approach in a draft guideline, which we explain in our article on BDD screening before cosmetic procedures. Recording a decision not to treat, and the reason for it, is as important as recording a decision to proceed. Managing and documenting expectations is one of the most effective ways to prevent a complaint, because many complaints are really about a gap between what the patient expected and what they received.
What the record must show
If a complaint arises, the question is whether a proper consent process happened, and the answer comes almost entirely from the record. A defensible note shows the indication and the patient's goals, the material risks discussed, the reasonable alternatives including no treatment, the time for reflection given, the patient's questions and your answers, any written information provided, and that consent was taken by the person performing the procedure. Our line-by-line standard for aesthetic consultation notes sets out exactly what to write, and it should sit within your consent process and your wider clinical governance framework.
Common assumptions
Tap each card to compare the assumption with what the law and the guidance say.
Consent for photographs and personal data
Clinical photographs are part of consent and part of the record, and they carry their own duties under the UK GDPR, because an image that reveals a patient's health is special category data. A photograph taken as part of care belongs in the record, but using the same image for teaching or for marketing is a separate purpose that needs its own, specific consent. Our guide to clinical photographs, consent and storage explains the three different consents and why images should not be left on a personal phone.
Consent across the professions
Although the leading cases concern doctors, the duty applies to everyone who treats, through their own regulator. The General Dental Council's Standards for the Dental Team require dentists to obtain valid consent and to give patients a reasonable amount of time to consider information before deciding. The Nursing and Midwifery Council Code requires nurses to get properly informed consent and document it before any action. The General Pharmaceutical Council's guidance on consent requires that the person is acting voluntarily and is under no undue pressure. The Joint Council for Cosmetic Practitioners and the Cosmetic Practice Standards Authority publish a Code of Practice that applies the same time-for-reflection and voluntariness principles to all their registrants. A clinic that employs several types of practitioner should run one consistent consent process rather than several informal habits. For implants, orthodontic aligners and whitening, our article on dental consent after Montgomery applies these rules treatment by treatment.
Children, age limits and the future of regulation
The direction of regulation is towards tighter control of who may perform cosmetic procedures and for whom. The Department of Health and Social Care consultation of 21 October 2026 proposes that the listed high-risk procedures would be restricted to people aged 18 and over, except for NHS provision or treatment of a medical condition, and that providers would need to register with the Care Quality Commission. Our article on the high-risk cosmetic procedures consultation sets out what is proposed. These are proposals until regulations are made, but the trend is clear, and a clinic that already treats consent as a documented process rather than a signature is well placed for whatever the scheme requires.
What to do in clinic
The steps below turn the law and the guidance into a process you can run and evidence.
- Separate the consultation from the treatment. Give written information at the consultation and take or confirm consent at a later point, with time for reflection proportionate to the intervention, and at least two weeks for cosmetic surgery.
- Have the treating clinician take consent. The doctor, dentist or prescriber who will perform the procedure should hold the discussion personally.
- Discuss material risks and the option of no treatment. Tailor the risks to this patient, cover reasonable alternatives, and record that you did.
- Check capacity where it is in doubt. Apply the section 3 test, remember that an unwise decision is not incapacity, and record the assessment.
- Screen for vulnerability and unrealistic expectations. Record a decision not to treat where that is the right call, and the reason for it.
- Record consent for images separately. Note consent for the clinical record, and take separate written consent for any teaching or marketing use.
- Write the note as if it will be read in court. Capture the discussion, the time given, the questions asked and who took consent, following a consistent standard.
- Audit your process, not just your forms. Check the records against this standard periodically, because a good form with an empty note does not protect anyone.
Interactive
Would your consent process stand up to scrutiny?
Tick each item your clinic has in place. Nothing you select is sent anywhere.
Where to go next
Consent is the foundation, and the related duties build on it: the record, the time for reflection, the images, and what happens when a complaint arrives. An independent consent audit reviews your policy, your forms and your records against the law and the guidance in this guide, and the free Medicolegal Readiness Score gives a quick view of where you stand. For any live complaint, claim or regulatory matter, speak to your indemnity provider or a solicitor.
Frequently asked questions
Valid consent needs a patient with capacity, who is acting voluntarily, and who has been given the material risks and reasonable alternatives for their situation, with enough time to decide. Since Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board the test is a tailored dialogue, not a signed form.
No. A signature records that a decision was made, but it does not prove that the material risks and alternatives were discussed. The law and the GMC guidance look at the quality of the discussion and the record of it, which is why a form with an empty note offers little protection.
Capacity is governed by the Mental Capacity Act 2005. You presume capacity, and where it is in genuine doubt you apply the section 3 test: can the patient understand the relevant information, retain it, use or weigh it, and communicate their decision. An unwise decision is not, by itself, a lack of capacity.
The clinician who will perform the procedure. The GMC asks doctors to get consent from the patient themselves, and the Royal College of Surgeons asks for consent to be obtained in writing by the operating surgeon. It should not be delegated to non-treating staff.
Yes, through their own regulators. The GDC, NMC and GPhC each require valid, informed and voluntary consent, and the JCCP and CPSA Code of Practice applies the same time-for-reflection principles to its registrants. The underlying standard is the same across professions.
Yes. A clinical photograph is part of the record, but using it for teaching or marketing is a separate purpose that needs its own specific consent, and the image is special category data under the UK GDPR. Clinical use and marketing use are separate decisions and should be recorded separately.
Sources
- Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board [2015] UKSC 11 and McCulloch and others v Forth Valley Health Board [2023] UKSC 26, The National Archives, Find Case Law.
- General Medical Council. Guidance for doctors who offer cosmetic interventions, in effect 1 June 2016, and Decision making and consent, in effect 9 November 2020.
- Royal College of Surgeons of England. Professional Standards for Cosmetic Surgery, April 2016.
- Mental Capacity Act 2005, section 1, section 2 and section 3, legislation.gov.uk.
- General Dental Council. Standards for the Dental Team, principle 3: obtain valid consent.
- Nursing and Midwifery Council. The Code. General Pharmaceutical Council. Guidance on consent.
- Joint Council for Cosmetic Practitioners and Cosmetic Practice Standards Authority. Code of Practice, third edition, March 2023.
- Department of Health and Social Care. Restrictions on the performance of high-risk cosmetic and wellbeing procedures in England, consultation published 21 October 2026.
Filed under: Consent · Aesthetics · Governance



