When a procedure goes wrong in a private clinic, the first instinct of a careful clinician is usually to fix the clinical problem and then think about what to say. The law in England reverses part of that order of thinking. A clinic registered with the Care Quality Commission carries a statutory duty to tell the patient, in person and with an apology, when certain kinds of harm occur, and the individual clinician carries a parallel professional duty to be open and honest whatever the setting. The two duties are often confused with each other, and a call for evidence by the Department of Health and Social Care found that many respondents did not know they were distinct.
This article explains how the duty of candour applies in private and independent clinics: which incidents trigger the statutory duty, what the clinic must do and by when, how the professional duty differs, and how to build a process that works on the day. It is written for doctors, dentists, nurses and nurse prescribers, pharmacist prescribers, allied health professionals in private practice, and the clinic owners and registered managers who hold responsibility for the service.
What is the duty of candour in a private clinic?
There are two duties, and they bind different people. The statutory duty of candour is set out in regulation 20 of the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014. It applies to the registered person, which means the provider registered with CQC, and it requires that provider to act in an open and transparent way with relevant persons in relation to care and treatment provided to service users. It applies to independent providers as well as to NHS bodies, with a different harm threshold for each, which is explained below.
The professional duty of candour is set out in the joint guidance of the General Medical Council and the Nursing and Midwifery Council, Openness and honesty when things go wrong, last updated on 13 December 2024. It states that every health and care professional must be open and honest with patients and people in their care when something goes wrong. The General Dental Council publishes its own guidance on the professional duty of candour for dental professionals, and its Standards for the Dental Team require that "You must record all patient safety incidents and report them promptly to the appropriate national body."
What counts as a notifiable safety incident for an independent provider?
The statutory duty is triggered by a notifiable safety incident, and the regulation defines that term differently for health service bodies and for every other registered provider. For a private or independent clinic, paragraph 9 applies. A notifiable safety incident is any unintended or unexpected incident that occurred in respect of a service user during the provision of a regulated activity which, in the reasonable opinion of a health care professional, appears to have resulted in one of the following:
- the death of the service user, where the death relates directly to the incident rather than to the natural course of the illness or underlying condition;
- an impairment of the sensory, motor or intellectual functions of the service user which has lasted, or is likely to last, for a continuous period of at least 28 days;
- changes to the structure of the service user's body;
- prolonged pain or prolonged psychological harm, each defined as lasting, or likely to last, for a continuous period of at least 28 days; or
- the shortening of the life expectancy of the service user.
Paragraph 9 also covers an incident that requires treatment by a health care professional in order to prevent any of those outcomes. That second limb matters in procedural practice, because a complication that is recognised and treated promptly may never reach the 28-day mark precisely because it was treated. The regulation does not provide a list of complications that count, so the decision turns on the facts and on the reasonable opinion of a health care professional. Whatever the conclusion, the reasoning should be written down at the time.
Check your understanding
Illustrative scenario: in a CQC-registered clinic, a patient develops signs of compromised blood supply shortly after a procedure. The clinician recognises it and gives emergency treatment, and the patient recovers fully within a week. Could the statutory duty of candour still apply?
For providers that are not health service bodies, a notifiable safety incident includes an unintended or unexpected incident that requires treatment by a health care professional to prevent outcomes such as changes to the structure of the body or prolonged harm. Full recovery does not of itself remove the duty. Whether this particular event was unintended or unexpected is a judgement on the facts, which is why the reasoning should be recorded and, if in doubt, discussed with your indemnity provider. This scenario is illustrative and is not a real case.
The threshold for NHS bodies under paragraph 8 is framed differently, referring to death and to severe harm, moderate harm or prolonged psychological harm, with moderate harm defined by reference to a moderate increase in treatment and significant but not permanent harm. Clinicians who work across NHS and private settings should not assume that the test they use in one applies in the other.
What the clinic must do, step by step
Regulation 20 sets out a sequence. On becoming aware that a notifiable safety incident has occurred, the registered person must, as soon as reasonably practicable, notify the relevant person, and must provide reasonable support to them in relation to the incident. The relevant person is normally the patient, or a person lawfully acting on their behalf where the patient has died, is under 16 and not competent, or is 16 or over and lacks capacity in relation to the matter.
Interactive
The regulation 20 sequence after a notifiable safety incident
On becoming aware
Recognise the incident
A health care professional forms a reasonable opinion that an unintended or unexpected incident has caused, or required treatment to prevent, one of the outcomes in paragraph 9. The duty runs from the point the provider becomes aware.
As soon as reasonably practicable
Tell the patient in person
One or more representatives of the provider notify the relevant person in person. The notification gives a true account of all the facts known about the incident at that date, advises what further enquiries are appropriate, and includes an apology.
At the same time
Record the conversation
The in-person notification must be recorded in a written record that the provider keeps securely. The provider must also offer reasonable support to the relevant person.
Afterwards
Follow up in writing
The provider sends a written notification containing the account of the facts, details of the further enquiries, the results of any further enquiries, and an apology.
Throughout
Keep copies
The provider keeps a copy of all correspondence with the relevant person. If the person cannot be contacted or declines to speak to the provider, a written record of the attempts must be kept instead.
The regulation defines an apology as "an expression of sorrow or regret in respect of a notifiable safety incident". It is not a confession of fault, and the law says so expressly. Section 2 of the Compensation Act 2006 provides that "An apology, an offer of treatment or other redress, shall not of itself amount to an admission of negligence" or breach of statutory duty. The GMC and NMC guidance makes the same point: "Apologising to a patient does not mean that you are admitting legal liability for what has happened."
This distinction is worth holding onto, because candour is not a finding that the care was negligent. Whether care fell below the standard is judged by the separate legal tests explained in our guide to the Bolam test and the standard of care. A complication can occur after impeccable care and still trigger the duty to tell the patient openly what has happened.
What happens if a clinic does not comply?
The statutory duty has teeth. Regulation 22 makes it an offence for a registered person to fail to comply with regulation 20(2)(a) and (3), which are the requirements to notify the relevant person and to do so in person, with a true account, the appropriate enquiries, an apology and a written record. Under regulation 23(5) the offence is punishable on summary conviction by a fine not exceeding level 4 on the standard scale. Regulation 22(4) provides a defence where the provider took all reasonable steps and exercised all due diligence to prevent the breach.
The Department of Health and Social Care, in its report on the findings of its call for evidence on the statutory duty, states that the duty is enforced by CQC and that CQC can "bring criminal prosecutions without needing to first serve a warning notice." That is different from many other regulatory breaches, where a warning would normally come first. For a clinic, the practical defence is a documented process that staff actually follow, which is also what the due diligence defence looks for.
23%
of respondents to the Department of Health and Social Care's call for evidence said the duty is correctly complied with when a notifiable safety incident occurs. The call for evidence received 261 responses.
The same report found that 40 per cent of respondents thought the purpose of the statutory duty was clear and well understood, and that 54 per cent did not think staff working for health and social care providers know of and understand its requirements. It also recorded that many respondents did not know the professional duty is distinct from the statutory organisational duty. These are views from a call for evidence rather than a measure of compliance, but they show where the confusion lies.
Common assumptions
Tap each card to compare the assumption with the position.
The professional duty of candour for every clinician
The professional duty applies to the individual, whether they work in a CQC-registered hospital, an unregistered aesthetic practice, a dental surgery or a pharmacy. The GMC and NMC guidance says that every health and care professional must tell the person, or where appropriate their advocate, carer or family, when something has gone wrong; apologise; offer an appropriate remedy or support to put matters right if possible; and explain fully the short and long term effects of what has happened. It also says professionals must be open and honest with their regulators, raising concerns where appropriate, and that they must not stop someone from raising concerns.
The guidance gives useful practical detail. It says that you should speak to the patient as soon as possible after you realise something has gone wrong, and that you should share all you know and believe to be true about what went wrong and why. It describes three things patients expect as part of an apology: what happened, what can be done to deal with any harm caused, and what will be done to prevent someone else being harmed. It also notes that patients are likely to find a personalised apology more meaningful, giving the example "I am sorry". On near misses, it says you must use your professional judgement when considering whether to tell patients about them.
Candour sits naturally alongside consent. The conversation before treatment, which our article on material risk after Montgomery covers in detail, is where the patient learns what might go wrong. The candour conversation is where they learn what did. A consent discussion that named the risk makes the later conversation easier and more credible, and the guide to the consent process sets out how the two connect.
Who does this affect beyond aesthetics?
Aesthetic and cosmetic practice is an obvious setting, because procedural complications such as those discussed in our vascular occlusion consent guide can require urgent treatment to prevent lasting harm. The duty is much wider than that. Where the service is registered with CQC, it applies equally to private GP and doctor services, independent hospitals and day surgery units, dental practices, ophthalmic and oculoplastic services, dermatology and minor surgery clinics, physiotherapy and other allied health services, and the managers who are accountable for them. Pharmacist and nurse prescribers working in these settings carry the professional duty personally, whatever the registration status of the clinic. The medical aesthetics page sets out how we work with clinics in that sector specifically.
The position differs across the United Kingdom. This article concerns England. Scotland has its own organisational duty of candour in Part 2 of the Health (Tobacco, Nicotine etc. and Care) (Scotland) Act 2016, which was fully in force from 1 April 2018, and in Wales the Welsh Government states that NHS organisations have a duty to be open and honest with people they are caring for if things go wrong. Clinicians practising outside England should check the rules that apply where they work.
The statutory duty has also been under review. The Department of Health and Social Care published terms of reference for a review of the statutory duty on 6 December 2023, and on 26 November 2024 it published the findings of its call for evidence, which it described as published ahead of a final response to the review. The findings summarise what respondents said and do not themselves change the law. Regulation 20 remains the governing provision, and clinics should check GOV.UK for any later response.
Building a duty of candour process in your clinic
The duty is easiest to meet when the decisions have been made in advance. The steps below are practical suggestions for a private or independent clinic, not legal advice, and they should sit within your wider clinical governance framework.
- Write a short candour policy. State who decides whether an incident is notifiable, using the paragraph 9 criteria, and who will speak to the patient. Name a deputy for when that person is unavailable.
- Record the decision either way. When an unintended or unexpected event occurs, document whether it met the threshold and why. A recorded decision that an event was not notifiable is far easier to explain later than silence.
- Prepare the conversation. Agree who will meet the patient in person, what facts are known, what further enquiries will follow, and how the apology will be given. Offer support, such as a direct contact number and follow-up care.
- Use a written follow-up template. Build a letter that covers the account of the facts, the enquiries, the results when known, and an apology, so that the written notification is not delayed while someone drafts it from scratch.
- Keep the file together. Store the record of the in-person conversation, all correspondence and any record of unsuccessful attempts to make contact, alongside the clinical notes described in our guide to writing aesthetic consultation notes.
- Connect candour to complaints and indemnity. A notifiable incident often becomes a complaint. Our article on the first 72 hours after a patient complaint explains how the processes run side by side. Tell your indemnity provider early, and take advice from them or a solicitor on any live complaint, claim or regulatory matter.
- Train the team. Make sure every clinician and manager knows the difference between the statutory and professional duties, and audit the process after each incident.
Interactive
Is your clinic ready to meet the duty of candour?
Tick each item your clinic has in place. Nothing you select is sent anywhere.
Candour is ultimately a test of whether a clinic's systems work under pressure, on the day something has gone wrong. An independent consent and governance audit can review your policy, templates and records against regulation 20, and the free Medicolegal Readiness Score gives a quick view of where your current systems stand.
Frequently asked questions
Yes, if the clinic is registered with the Care Quality Commission. Regulation 20 of the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014 applies to every registered provider, and paragraph 9 sets the harm threshold for providers that are not NHS bodies.
The regulation requires the provider to notify the relevant person as soon as reasonably practicable after becoming aware of a notifiable safety incident. It does not set a fixed number of days. The GMC and NMC guidance says you should speak to the patient as soon as possible after you realise something has gone wrong.
No. Section 2 of the Compensation Act 2006 provides that an apology, an offer of treatment or other redress does not of itself amount to an admission of negligence or breach of statutory duty, and the GMC and NMC guidance says that apologising does not mean you are admitting legal liability.
The statutory duty in regulation 20 applies to registered providers, so it may not apply to an unregistered service. Every doctor, nurse, dentist, pharmacist and other registered professional still has a professional duty of candour, set out by their regulator, which applies in every setting.
Failing to comply with regulation 20(2)(a) and (3) is an offence under regulation 22, punishable on summary conviction by a fine not exceeding level 4 on the standard scale. The Department of Health and Social Care notes that CQC can prosecute without first serving a warning notice. If you are facing a live matter, speak to your indemnity provider or a solicitor.
Sources
- The Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014, regulation 20, Duty of candour, legislation.gov.uk.
- The Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014, regulation 22, Offences, and regulation 23, Offences: penalties, legislation.gov.uk.
- Care Quality Commission. Regulation 20: Duty of candour, guidance updated 30 June 2022.
- General Medical Council and Nursing and Midwifery Council. Openness and honesty when things go wrong: the professional duty of candour, last updated 13 December 2024. See also the GMC guidance page.
- General Dental Council. The professional duty of candour, and Standards for the Dental Team, Principle 1.
- Compensation Act 2006, section 2, Apologies, offers of treatment or other redress, legislation.gov.uk.
- Department of Health and Social Care. Findings of the call for evidence on the statutory duty of candour, published 26 November 2024.
- Department of Health and Social Care. Duty of candour review: terms of reference, published 6 December 2023.
- Health (Tobacco, Nicotine etc. and Care) (Scotland) Act 2016, Part 2, Duty of candour, legislation.gov.uk.
- Welsh Government. Duty of candour, consultation outcome, last updated 18 April 2023.
Filed under: Governance · Regulation · Complaints & claims



